Best Mattress for Graco Pack n Play Reviews 2019

Share

Motherhood can be as overwhelming as it is rewarding. Sifting through the available products and trying to decide which product is best and safest for your little one can be a daunting task. Many parents don’t know that mattresses exist specifically for Pack n Plays!

Let us handle the work for you and lay out the best mattress for Graco Pack n Play. You’ll find honest and detailed reviews of high quality, high sustainable, and highly durable mattresses. We’ve compiled a list of the top five mattresses that can fit your many parenting needs.

Our measure of “best” includes safety, quality testing, comfort, standard compliance, easy of use, and ability to clean. We also factor in size, fit, reputation, weight, and manufacturer’s recommendations. You work hard enough, sit back and let us walk you through the top 5 models on the market right now!

Best Selling Mattress for Graco Pack and Play Recommendations

ImageNameDimensionWeightMaterial TypeWhere To Buy
Dream On Me Foam Pack and Play Mattress25.5 x 37.5 x 3 inches
3 pounds
Vinyl Check Price
LA Baby Waterproof Portable38 x 24 x 2 inches
2 poundsMultiCheck Price
Folding Pack-n-Play Mattress38 x 25 x 2 inches
7.5 poundsLead Free, BPA FreeCheck Price
NapYou Amazon Exclusive Pack n Play Mattress37.5 x 26 x 1.5 inches
6.46 pounds___Check Price
Dream On Me 3" Playard Mattress37.5 x 25.5 x 3 inches
3.5 poundsVinyl
Check Price

Top 5 Graco Pack n Play Mattress Reviews

1. Dream On Me Foam Pack and Play Mattress

Dream On Me is a family-owned company that designs, manufacturers, and supplies high quality baby products. A focus on quality is a focus on customers, and this mattress demonstrates that. The Foam Pack n Play Mattress features a completely foam mattress that has been subjected to multiple safety tests before release including flammability, phthalate, lead, and toxicity. Because the company designs the mattresses themselves, they have developed the foam mattress specifically with your baby’s growth in mind.  They have also included a reinforced border on the mattress to maintain shape and promote safety.

Best Mattress for Graco Pack n Play

The vinyl cover is removable, wipeable, and naturally preventative of mold and mildew. This helps to reduce odor from diaper and food spills.  The company specifically recommends pairing this mattress with the Graco Pack n Play brand, meaning they have done the job of measuring safety for you.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • A company focused on quality means they receive frequent client-feedback and depend on the customer rather than sales numbers.
  • The mattresses are often patented by the company meaning their high standards are implemented from start to end.
  • Quality-focused companies often have great customer service availability.
  • This mattress is lightweight, meaning cleaning will be a breeze.
  • A budget-friendly mattress without compromising quality.

Cons

  • Not a folding mattress, so this is not a great option for those looking to travel with the mattress.
  • Babies that have all ready developed a love of soft surfaces may not sleep well on this high-density mattress.

Verdict

You’re getting your money’s worth and more with this budget-friendly, high-quality mattress. We recommend this product for those wanting to explore same-room sleeping with their newborn, and those with accident-prone little ones.


 2. LA Baby Waterproof Portable/Mini Crib Mattress

LA Baby is a large, international company that has been in operation for nearly 80 years. Their goal is better products with a focus on baby safety and a quality focus. Again, we love a good quality-focused company because quality means customer satisfaction. They boast locations internationally, and as such have done research in a broader spectrum of sleep habits and environments than an average company.

Mattress for Graco Pack n Play Reviews

This lightweight mattress makes for easy cleaning, and the outer cover is stain-resistant. The mattress itself boasts non-toxicity and is the only mattress on our list that is portable without being foldable. It is composed of high-density material, great for baby’s sleep and mom’s peace of mind. The cover is a crisp white color and tear-resistant fabric, with a 1-year warranty to boot. The cover is also dust-mite resistant, not something you see in every mattress.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Company has high quality standards meaning the mattress is going to be made well or replaced quickly.
  • Company has won awards in Mom’s Choice, Family Choice, NAPPA, and Baby Maternity.
  • Mattress is lightweight without loss of density for baby’s safety.
  • Waterproof cover with protection against host of unpleasant microscopic pathogens.
  • Our most budget-friendly option on the review.

Cons

  • Mattress is an inch shorter than standard, be sure to measure your Pack n Play before ordering to assure a good fit.
  • Because this mattress is made to be portable, it is less durable compared to a heavier mattress intended for every-day use.

Verdict

This portable, waterproof mattress is great for those on-the-go or those needing a mattress that requires excessive cleaning and can withstand routine accidents and spills.


3. Folding Pack-n-Play Mattress by Sproutwise Kids

For those on the go, a foldable mattress can be a life-saver. This tri-fold mattress is not only convenient but comes with a cover made of high quality organic cotton. Pesticides from cotton fields have been shown to remain in cotton fabrics for years after the material has been spun into a finished project. While this means the cover is not waterproof, a waterproof pad can be fixed between the mattress and cover for leaks and spills. Keep baby safe and toxin-free with Sproutwise Kids’ staff-tested, organic mattress. This company also has a focus on sustainable materials, minimal packaging, and gives back 5% of their profits. For those who love both Earth and baby, this is a go-to win.

Best Graco Pack n Play Mattress

The mattress itself has a removable cover for easy washing and maintains good density with a size to weight ratio that lands it as the heaviest mattress on our list. Sproutwise Kids has a 100% money back guarantee and focus on environmental initiatives. It is not uncommon for portable mattresses to be easy to wear down and need replacing. Sproutwise responded to this by making the mattress from long-lasting materials.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Environment-minded company that focuses on safety over features.
  • Foldable mattress with travel bag for easy travel with Pack n Play.
  • Super soft natural latex foam provides an extra comfortable surface for play and rest.
  • Tested with Graco Pack n Play models, determined to be a perfect fit! (Measure your own model before purchase).
  • Great for those wanting to invest in a long-lasting product.

Cons

  • Recommended only for babies 6 months+ due to the nature of folding materials.
  • The cover nor mattress are waterproof, leaving potential for a messy cleanup without additional waterproof pads added.

Verdict

While this mattress is the highest budget item on our list, the spending power is on sustainability over features. This mattress is for the conscious parent on-the-go or with little ones who prefer soft surfaces.


4. NapYou Amazon Exclusive Pack n Play Mattress

NapYou provides a mix of quality and environment focus with memory foam material and an organic cotton cover. Another trifold, portable mattress, this one comes with rounded corners to assure a good fit with any model. Additionally, this model is marketed for use outside of the Pack n Play once your little one graduates to a toddler. NapYou focuses on a full line of memory-foam products and has cornered the marker in comfort. That being said, this product is recommended for babies far past the 4-month-old mark that categorizes them as a risk for SIDS. It would be an excellent nap or playtime option for babies 6-months or older.

pack n play mattress

A unique note to be made, when the mattress arrives it will be condensed. Be prepared to allow the mattress to expand to full size for 24-48 hours. The mattress itself is made with a combination of both cotton and polyester, meaning a water-proof cover or pad would be a good accessory to purchase with the mattress. The material is soft to the touch and comes with a minimalist black bag to store the mattress during travels.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Soft memory foam material great for babies used to soft surfaces.
  • Organic cotton cover to reduce exposure to chemicals.
  • Trifold mattress and black bag for easy travel.
  • Built to grow with your child and be used as a soft nap spot outside of the Pack n Play for toddlers.
  • Tested with Graco Pack n Play and found to be a great fit.

Cons

  • No waterproofing or anti-microbial properties, mattress will need to be reinforced for leaks and spills.
  • Memory foam material is not recommended for infants and/or night sleeping.

Verdict

This best toddler mattress provides a great, soft surface for fussy babies who are having a difficult time sleeping, and convenience for the parent on the go. Because of the material composition, it is recommended that this product be used with older babies only.


5. Dream On Me 3″ Playard Mattress

Dream On Me makes a second appearance on our review with their slightly weightier, always budget-friendly sister product. This 3lb mattress was designed for play in mind over sleep and accommodates a larger age range of babies due to its heavier density. This mattress is a safe option for those who use their Pack n Play most for safe play time.

pack and play mattress

This model has all the features of it’s sister product. From hypoallergenic, anti-bacterial, mold-preventative, and water-proof cover- to the rigorous testing and quality control processes that this quality-focused company places all their mattresses through. The company has even gone so far as to package this mattress in “Certified Frustration Free Packaging”. The mattress was made with Graco in mind, a quick measurement of your Pack n Play should reveal a good match. This brand utilizes lock-stitched binding to reduce unraveling leading to safety hazards. All their mattresses are manufactured in the US and certified to please.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • A durable mattress from a trustworthy company.
  • Great for playtime and sleep.
  • Waterproof mattress and hypoallergenic materials.
  • Good fit for Graco Pack n Play.
  • Pleasing, colorful print on mattress material.

Cons

  • Not ideal for frequent travelers.
  • The waterproof material can be considered noisy, be sure to place an extra blanket to reduce movement-related noise.

Verdict

This mattress is a great option for those looking for a safe nap and play time use of their Pack n Play. The mattress itself is budget-friendly and the company is dedicated to making sure you receive the best quality.


Why You Need a Graco Pack n Play Mattress

You love your Graco Pack n Play, and you love your baby. Help your baby love their Pack n Play by adding extra support, cushioning, and safety to their space. Keep reading to see how a mattress can provide a clean and comfortable addition for a happy baby.

  • Newborns

As a new parent, the risk of SIDs is a terrifying prospect. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) has done extensive research into this unfortunate syndrome and has released some helpful pointers for babies in the one to four-month-old risk rage. One of these findings is that infants who sleep in the same room as a parent greatly reduce their risk of SIDs. Graco Pack n Play has been awarded by pediatricians as a safe every-night sleep environment. These play yards go through a rigorous safety program with high standards centered around SIDs reduction.

Top Rated Mattress for Graco Pack n Play

So you have your play yard, great. Why replace the stock liner with a mattress? While the pad meets standards for play, it’s thin composition and water-proof materials are not the most inviting sleeping environment for newborns. Firm, supportive mattresses with removable covers that can be easily washed will more closely fit the needs of infants. Mattresses also provide hypoallergenic and anti-microbial properties in some cases, much better for baby’s airway.

  • 5 months +

It’s so exciting when babies begin to gain more motor control and the ability sit on their own. With these new skills comes increased mobility and a greater need for safe spaces for babies to play! Continuing to use a Pack n Play as a valuable resource for nap and play times keeps baby and mom both happy. Using a mattress provides a soft landing-pad for gentle tumbles and falls as babies explore their legs and ability to crawl. Mattresses also provide better surface area for toy spreads, and less space for enticing toys to slip between the cracks or beneath a thin pad. As baby transitions to crib or bed, their soft pack n play mattress will always be an available alternative to naps on-the-go.

What to look for in a Mattress for Graco Pack n Play

There are a lot of factors to consider when purchasing a mattress for your Pack n Play. The best mattress is going to be one that fits your needs, your baby’s needs, and your wallets. We’ve compile a list of the most important factors to consider when browsing for your family’s best fit.

  • Safety

Safety is the top consideration for both Graco and our team. It is important for parents to regularly review sleep guidelines by the American Academy of Pediatrics and be sure your mattress desires match suggested safety precautions. While we try to list the top quality products, guidelines can change and research can be the difference between a happy, healthy baby.

While using the mattress in the top level of a Pack n Play gives a bassinet-like feel, the thickness of the mattress can pose a hazard for babies that are mobile. Be sure to always supervise a child on the top level and place the mattress on the bottom level whenever possible.

Look for mattresses from established companies that meet guidelines such as ASTM and provide proof of BPA-free materials. Always send a mattress back to the supplier if it has been damaged in any way during the shipment process. And finally, buy new mattresses over used to assure condition safety.

  • Dimensions

While mattresses and Pack n Plays are subject to standardization and regulation, manufacturing variation can create small differences between one product and the next. As such, it’s key to measure both your Graco Pack n Play and compare the dimensions with your prospective mattress. No gaps 1” or larger should be present once mattress is installed. The mattress should fit snuggly into Pack n Play space without bending, bulking, or folding. There are too many available mattresses to choose from to settle for anything less than a perfect fit!

  • Density

Mattress density is how thick the inside of the mattress is, and is an important factor for baby’s airway.It is recommended that babies sleep on a firm surface, firmer than might feel comfortable to an adult.  When online shopping, compare the mattress thickness and weight to get a good idea of the mattress density.

Higher weight with lower thickness indicates a mattress will likely have good density. Once the mattress arrives or in store, lay it flat and press on it. The mattress should not mold to the shape of your hand and should return quickly to its natural shape. Otherwise it may not be a good match for your infant.

  • Composition

Mattresses for infants should be made of resilient, breathable material. Mattresses with small holes on the side let air flow in and out to accommodate with odor maintenance.Waterproof covers that can be removed for cleaning are ideal for diaper leaks. Waterproof vinyl covers are standard and safe for babies.

Many mattresses on the market today provide great features such as hypoallergenic, antimicrobial, and antibacterial properties. Determine which features are best for your family by considering the number of other children in your home, pets, environments that others regularly spend time in (ex. dirty warehouses at work), and the recommendation of your doctor.

  • Intended Use

Parents intending to use their Pack n Play for night sleeping should opt for firmer mattresses and avoid memory foam for infants. Mattresses used for play, or for older children, can be made of softer materials. Travel-oriented or on-the-go parents can opt for lightweight and/or foldable mattresses for easy storage and transport. Parents of children with digestive issues that lead to lots of spills would do well to utilize water-proof and stain-resistant mattresses, as well as lightweight material for easy movement during cleaning. Mattresses with covers can be removed easily for washing, while other mattresses need to be spot cleaned with soap and warm water.

  • Sustainability

Utilizing materials that are durable and environmentally-friendly are good for both mom and baby. Organic materials reduce exposure to toxins. Be sure to wash organic linens with organic detergent!

  • Budget

Sustainable and organic products are going to be costlier but should last a little longer than a non-organic counterpart. Strides in quality, standards, and safety mean most mattresses should be comparable in cost without compromising in any of these three areas.

  • Supplier Recommendation

Most suppliers provide a recommended weight range for their products based on product material and density. This is a good guide to follow to avoid safety hazards.

Conclusion

As we have seen, the good mattress for Graco Pack n Play depends on each family and their needs. There is a mattress available for almost any need that exists. Whether you are a traveling family that requires a lightweight folding mattress, a messy family that requires a breathable waterproof mattress, or a family that has never once moved their Pack n Play and wants the thickest heaviest mattress, there is a Pack n Play mattress that can meet your needs. Industry guidelines ensure that mattresses meet their standards, and we make sure to share with you an honest review of some of the highest quality mattresses available.

Leave a Comment: